We shouldn’t compare ourselves to others, but we do

Dr. Max Lempriere
Read in 1 minute

No sections available in this post.

Every chapter of your thesis, mapped onto a single page.

I asked 250 PhD examiners how they'd structure a thesis if they were starting again. Their answers fit on a single page. Download it free — and stop staring at a blank document wondering where to begin.

You keep coming back. There's a reason for that.

Come write with us live. Join the next Monday Focus Session — 9am UK time this Monday.

More often than not, comparing your progress to that of other PhD students you may know is futile at best and destructive at worst.
But in spite of that, it’s often impossible not to compare yourself. Perhaps it’s part of what makes us human to make sure we don’t fall behind or lose the pack.
This can present a paradox. We know that comparing one PhD to another is problematic, but yet we sometimes can’t help ourselves.
If this is a paradox you’re struggling with, it helps to consider who you are comparing yourself too. Are you comparing like for like? Are you comparing your progress to that of someone doing a similar study to yours, or using a similar research design or methodology? Are you comparing yourself to someone with similar levels of experience and expertise?
Or are you comparing apples and pears? Are you comparing your inductive approach with someone’s deductive approach and wondering why they’re ‘ahead’ of you?
If you really can’t help yourself, choose your point of comparison carefully. Otherwise, you may get a false sense of (in)security about the progress you are making.

What kind of PhD researcher are you?

Learn what’s actually making your PhD hard — and what to do about it.

This free assessment takes four minutes and involves twelve questions. Here's what you'll get:

  • Your doctoral profile — personalised to your answers
  • A personalised PDF report with a clear explanation of what's making your PhD hard
  • Specific recommendations based on where you actually are

Comments

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *